I'm seriously unconvinced. To me, it looks too expensive and too cheap, if that makes any sense. It's way too much to pay for a flimsy set-up, but the price is suspiciously low for a set-up that's well-engineered and durable.

It's one of those products that I would only buy after talking to a fellow gardener whose opinion and experience I knew who had used the model(s) I was considering.

galacticvoyeur has had considerable success starting seeds, and I believe Terry Garey has, too. Then again, Toad Hall had a front porch that was useful for hardening off seedlings once they were ready to move out of the front hall.