pegkerr: (I told no lies and of the truth all I co)
pegkerr ([personal profile] pegkerr) wrote2005-07-23 11:12 pm

Identity, again (and thinking about thinking out loud in general)

I had planned to do several more identity posts. One on being an American, or that is, a liberal/progressive American. Possibly one on being a Christian (after warning [livejournal.com profile] daisy_gamgee so she could stick her fingers in her ears first). One, perhaps, on being a wife (although upon further thought, I think that's pretty personal and should be kept just between Rob and me).

But I have found that the two posts I did on being a writer and on my day job cracked open something really painful in me. I wrote some stuff down I wasn't quite ready to face, and have been sort of dealing with the fall out ever since.

Some people have remarked, with a certain amount of awe, at how open I am about things in this journal. Well, of course, I thought (a little smugly) whenever people mentioned this, I'm used to it. It all seemed so familiar because I'd kept a daily paper journal for over twenty-seven years at the time I started my LJ. I discovered one difference right away, however, and it delighted me. I was doing what I was always doing, getting my thoughts down, but now people were responding to me. My thoughts were prompting conversations and questions, not the silence of an unresponsive page. I had wondered aloud about this a little in the past. But I started thinking about another aspect of that this weekend: when I write down stuff now, people are making judgments about what I say.

Really, most of you are kinder toward me than I ever am toward myself. But even when the reaction is wholly positive (as it often has been), it is different than when you confide dangerous thoughts to mere paper. Thoughts like I don't know what I'm doing. I may never write fiction again. I feel like a failure. Mere paper doesn't argue with you. And you can put the thought down on paper and then shove it into a drawer and the page you have written on will never say back to you (unlike Livejournal), "Well? What are you going to do about it?" Which means you can go on pretending that you don't have to deal with that dangerous thought. You put it down on paper, just to release the tension, and then ignore the fact that you have done so.

But no. I put it out on LiveJournal instead. Which made it seem so much more dangerous, so much more painful. More than I realized it would when I wrote the entry. Most of the time, this simply isn't a problem, but this time it was. I don't know why. I am at a particularly low ebb right now; is this part of it? I have cried an awful lot in the last two weeks, sometimes on the phone with [livejournal.com profile] kijjohnson on the other end, huge racking sobs that make my throat and eyes hurt, that make me look like a fright.

I want to keep doing what I have been doing in this journal. I want to keep telling the truth.

Just be aware that some of the truths I have said lately have been very difficult for me to bear, once I've put them out there. And I'm sort of absorbed right now in coping with the cleanup.

[identity profile] jonquil.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 04:35 am (UTC)(link)
Remember that it is possible to lock journal entries down so that nobody but you can read them. That lets you have the joy of thinking out loud without worrying about the audience.

And, yes, you're working through some hard painful thoughts right now; I wince in empathy.
redbird: closeup of me drinking tea, in a friend's kitchen (Default)

[personal profile] redbird 2005-07-24 03:27 pm (UTC)(link)
Note also that it's possible to disable comments, if you don't want that feedback on a particular entry.

[identity profile] pegkerr.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 05:31 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes, and I have done that at times in the past.

[identity profile] merebrillante.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 04:38 am (UTC)(link)
FWIW, I've been especially emotional lately too, and I'm starting to wonder if it's something in the stars or in the water. I decided today I needed a break from all the heavy-osity and put on Waiting for Guffman. To my horror, I found myself getting weepy at the song "A Penny for Your Thoughts."

As for revealing the angsty, horrible side of the writing life for all the world to see, I've done that a number of times. I'm still up in the air about whether it's a good idea or not. Because I have this sneaking suspicion that when I put those thoughts on LJ instead of on paper, I'm wanting to hear a chorus cry out encouragement. And I think people have been encouraging, but that's never been enough. What it's come down to is that the encouragement has to come from either inside me or that evanescent thing some of us call "God."

[identity profile] elisem.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 04:39 am (UTC)(link)
I got no words, but I leave you a companionable quiet moment of company, plus a hug if you could use one.

[identity profile] juliansinger.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 05:03 am (UTC)(link)
I respect your truths. And I'll hear 'em when you can say 'em.

[identity profile] kijjohnson.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 05:38 am (UTC)(link)
Painful truths have a way of thrashing out of our control. The woman of courage does what you're doing: faces those truths and then learns what she can. You have my love, sweetheart.

dropping in to leave the following . . .

[identity profile] sisyphus91.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 06:30 am (UTC)(link)
As I become more comfortable with my LJ, I find myself writing more personal observations as well. I pared down my friends list a little over a year ago and have since began sharing the things that rattle around my mind more than before. The things I would normally put in a regular journal. I don't do it for the response per se, but if I get one then it's great. I like the idea I have it all here. I've used it for my personal writing, fanfic drabble, the odd thought here and there that may turn into something one day, lesson plans, other things I want ot be able to find later on, just about anything.

Fanfiction brought me to LJ, but this year I used it as more of a tool than I did previously.

at times I am concerned about how the posts will be received, for most are not terrible deep or awe inspiring, but for the most part I just post as things occur to me.

Thanks for sharing.

[identity profile] rachelhduncan.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 08:05 am (UTC)(link)
I don't know how relevant this is, but you got me thinking, Peg.

I think as I writer, I'm constantly looking for some kind of feedback from my written words. The internet is the mother of all instant gratification. Naturally, these things combined can be a very powerful, and yes, very dangerous tool.

Recently because of ... situations, I've had to delete my old journal go "friends only" in my a new one, something I swore I'd never do when I started it. Already it's changed. I don't post as often because it's not the same feeling. There was always the idea that there was someone out there reading and responding to wat I said... not just some one, but lots of someones, even if they didn't comment, I knew that I was being read. I like/crave/need/can'texist without that feeling.

Even so, I've noticed a definite spike in my ability to focus on my fiction since quitting the public posts. Perhaps depriving myself of the attention (in moderation) will help me stay on task.

...and the possibility exists that I'll make public posts again in it someday. Heck, probably sooner than later. I'm a Leo; we can't be quiet.

...as evidenced in this absurdly lengthly comment. Pardon my intrusion. ;)

[identity profile] jemyl.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 03:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Peg, you are doing very, very well. You do more than I ever could manage in a similar situation. Also, it is just fine to ignore all the comments, decide not to deal with whatever until later in your life and/or to figure we commenters are all just a bunch of busybodies who know nothing of you and your life and laugh at our dumb ideas. Point is, Peg, we really don't know you and are likely off base with our suggestions. You know yourself better than anyone else and will do what is right for you. I grieves me that my comments may have made you cry because you are so far ahead of most people in both self knowledge and the ability to do just the right thing for yourself and your family. Also, when the body is ill, the mind plays awful tricks on us, at least mine does.

I know, from what you have posted, that you are a Christian. I also know from what you have indicated in the past that you pray over your concerns. Isaiah 40 comes to mind. You are doing well and will do great things, Peg.

[identity profile] charlietudor.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 04:31 pm (UTC)(link)
...(after warning [livejournal.com profile] daisy_gamgee so she could stick her fingers in her ears first)...

;D

Just so you know--I haven't commented on those posts, but I have read them and they've given me things to think about in my own life. They've been valuable, much as they've cost you; I just wish they hadn't cost you pain.

[identity profile] mckitterick.livejournal.com 2005-07-24 08:27 pm (UTC)(link)
The brave life, the one about growth and learning, is often painful. I've been facing that myself a lot lately, though I haven't been putting much of it on LJ, partly because people can be judgemental and partly because the self-examination is still in-process. Also partly because I tend to reach out less and less the more down I get, and I think I'm about as depressed lately as I've ever been. Talking to friends, especially when it might elicit disapproval - or worse, no response at all - is especially hard when I'm already at my ragged edge.

Funny, I think I've said more in this response than I have in my own LJ lately. I suspect it's because fewer of my own friends will read this.

Keep up the self-examination and growth. Be brave. You're well-loved.

Hugs,
Chris

[identity profile] alfreda89.livejournal.com 2005-07-25 02:21 am (UTC)(link)
Perhaps many of us have reached the age where we are re-examining our lives. If we don't comment, it's because we know we can't really help you. We can only assure you that we read, and we think, and we hope you find the answers that suit you best.

And we wish you luck and love.

[identity profile] mayakda.livejournal.com 2005-07-25 01:39 pm (UTC)(link)
Your identity posts have been resonating with me.
*hugs*